Concrete Pool Resurfacing vs. Pool Replacement: Which One Saves More Money?

Concrete pools are durable and always in style, but even the strongest pools need TLC after a while. When your pool begins to show signs of aging, you will have to make a very important choice: concrete pool resurfacing or replacing it entirely. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, but knowing what goes into the costs and long-term effects can help you make the most informed decision for your wallet and your situation.

What Is Concrete Pool Resurfacing, and How Much Does It Cost?

Concrete pool resurfacing is the process of restoring the pool's interior surface to its original condition through repairs and refinishing. This may involve draining the pool, repairing cracks or chips, using a new finish (such as plaster, aggregate, or tile), and refilling it.

Lifespan of Finishes:

1. Plaster lasts for 10 years at a cost of about $4 per square foot.

2. Aggregate finishes (e.g., pebbles) for 20+ years at a cost of $10 per square foot.

3. Tile is the strongest but also the most costly, reaching up to $35 per square foot.

What Does Pool Replacement Entail?

Pool replacement involves the removal of your current concrete pool and the installation of a new one. This is a far more involved process that involves demolition, excavation, and construction of a new pool from the ground up.

1. Cost Range: Replacing a concrete pool costs between $50,000 and $95,000 or more, depending on the nature of the replacement (e.g., fiberglass or vinyl liner).

2. Timeframe: Pool replacement lasts much longer than resurfacing by several months in some instances.

When It's Necessary:

1. Extreme structural damage that cannot be repaired.

2. Desire to convert to a new material type (e.g., fiberglass).

3. Major overhauls involving changing the shape or size of the pool.

What Are the Major Cost Elements for Each Solution?

Resurfacing Costs

1. Pool Size: The larger the pool, the more materials and labor it takes.

2. Finish Type: Low-end finishes, such as plaster, are less expensive than luxury finishes, such as tile.

3. Repairs: Cracks or leaks to repair contribute to the final cost.

4. Labor Rates: Labor rates differ depending on the area but usually run between $45 and $65 per hour.

Replacement Costs

1. Demolition: Disassembling an existing concrete pool is $5,000 to $15,0005.

2. New Construction: The most expensive is constructing a new pool.

3. Permits and Approvals: Added expense to meet local ordinance requirements.

4. Landscaping: Bringing your lawn back to normal after construction is added to the bill.

Which Option Saves More Money?

Short-Term Savings

• Resurfacing is a fraction of the cost of a pool replacement. 

• If your pool shell is structurally sound, but its surface has issues, resurfacing will keep you out of tens of thousands of dollars and add an extra 10–20 years to its lifespan.

Long-term thoughts

• While it is costlier upfront, in some situations, replacement will ultimately prove cheaper:

• If there's serious damage or leaks within your current pool that need repairs again and again.

• If you are considering major renovations such as altering the size or installing features like spas or tanning ledges.

How Do You Choose Between Resurfacing and Replacement?

Ask yourself 

• Is my pool structurally sound with only cosmetic problems? If so, resurface.

• Should I alter my pool's shape or material? If so, replacement might be the way to go.

Most people find resurfacing more budget-friendly!

When deciding between concrete pool resurfacing and replacement, resurfacing often saves more money while still delivering excellent results. It’s an ideal option for addressing cosmetic issues and extending your pool’s lifespan without breaking the bank. However, if your pool has severe structural problems or you’re looking for a complete overhaul, replacement may be worth the investment